On finding atheism too simple

Alister McGrath explains what first excited him about Christianity.

close

Summary

Alister McGrath explains what first excited him about Christianity.

Transcript

Well my own personal journey is that of a gradual movement from atheism to Christianity. And I think that one of the reasons I moved away from my early atheism was my realisation that just … it was just too simple, that actually it failed to do justice to the complexity of life. It was like what C. S. Lewis once called a glib and shallow rationalism, which actually failed to engage life’s complexity. And life is so complicated, you just cannot live with a simplistic philosophy which portrays everything as being black or white and fails to realise that real life is multiple shades of grey.

I think one of my main concerns in transitioning from atheism to Christianity was my growing realisation that atheism was not generative. What I mean by that is, it doesn’t excite you, it doesn’t open up new intellectual possibilities. I think when I grasped what Christianity was all about – I think I had a very bad misunderstanding of what Christianity was – when I saw what it really was, it kind of in a way opened up new ways of thinking, new ways of seeing reality. And I suddenly thought, this makes sense, this is exciting – and that was the end of my commitment to atheism.

Now let me emphasise, in moving from atheism to Christianity, I don’t rubbish atheism. Only some fool would rubbish an alternative viewpoint, it usually means they haven’t understood it. I respect atheism, but I do believe it to be inadequate. And to me Christianity, if you like, gives depth to what is otherwise a very simplistic, shallow vision of reality. And we need that depth if we’re going to be authentic human beings in this world.